Back

Kritarth Mittal • Soshals

Founder, Soshals | C... • 1m

When will Indians stop demonising wealth? Anyway, let me educate you. In India, "fair use" means limited use of copyrighted material without the copyright holder's permission, primarily for specific purposes like research, criticism, and reporting. → The more factual or non-fiction the work, the more likely fair use may be accepted. → Uses like criticism, commentary, or teaching are considered fair. → Only if the use negatively impacts the market for the original work or its value, it's less likely to be deemed fair use. Ofcourse a lot of Youtubers are now making good money but how is that a valid argument against them? Anyone who thinks this is fair/legal, needs to realise that if ANI wanted to play fair, they would've asked for content removal. They would've asked for royalties/revenue share. They would've sent a legal notice. But ANI strategically filed 8 strikes and threatened the creator with account deletion, which also happens to be a well practiced play. Legalities aside, there are some things you just don't do out of ethics and mutual respect. ANI just figured that creators will pay the ransom simply out of desparation. Mohak Mangal just didn't play along and hence, the public dialogue now.

1 Reply
14
Replies (1)

More like this

Recommendations from Medial

Image Description

Chamarti Sreekar

Passionate about Pos... • 1m

if you asked 50+ startup founders: What’s your #1 pain point? 80% would've said: "I don't know if people will actually use it"

1 Reply
12
Image Description

Ravi Handa

Early Retiree | Fina... • 1m

ANI is a propaganda machine, no doubt. But on the Mohak Mangal issue, they’re technically in the right. They sell content for a living. If creators use their footage without permission, ANI striking them isn’t censorship. It is CAPITALISM ! For th

See More
1 Reply
1
18

Saket Sambhav

 • 

ADJUVA LEGAL® • 1m

Big Media vs. YouTuber: Silencing Critics or Fair Game? 🤔 News agency ANI is suing YouTuber Mohak Mangal. Defamation, copyright, the works. Standard legal toolkit. But step back. When a media powerhouse legally targets a critic: ✅ Can it also be

See More
Reply
3
Image Description
Image Description

Siddharth Chopra

Tech | AI | Business • 6m

Just got a notice from Paytm asking me to delete this video because I used their logo 😕. As far as I know, logos/trademarks used for commentary or criticism are usually allowed under fair use laws. Can anyone help me out with this?

3 Replies
3
13
Image Description
Image Description

DK

 • 

Ride • 1y

AI powered Paralegal for lawyers. Do legal research and draft documents quickly. Me and my friend made a prototype, won in a hackathon, few judges asked if they could use it today at their jobs.

4 Replies
2
11

Saksham

Legal Advisor! • 1y

Trademark infringement in India is a serious concern. Key points include: 1. Trademark Ownership: •Registration: Protect your mark under the Trade Marks Act, 1999. •Common Law Rights: Rights through actual use, but limited. 2. Likelihood of Confusi

See More
Reply
1
7

Kimiko

Startups | AI | info... • 1m

Govt Goes Open Source Amid ANI Copyright Storm! In a bold move following the ANI copyright controversy, the Indian government has unlocked its media vaults: • Doordarshan, AIR, and PIB content is now free for creators to use across platforms like Yo

See More
Reply
5
Image Description

Harsh Singh

Founder @Luma Space • 4m

The last time I opened the Play Store to download Medial was a year ago. I remember that as a kid, I used to explore the Play Store frequently. Do you also feel that the use of the Play Store has declined? or I'm the exception? 🥲

1 Reply
1
24

Shan Trades

I am full time trade... • 2m

Fair value gap is one of the most important tool in my trading , I have seen many use it in wrong way .

Reply
3

Download the medial app to read full posts, comements and news.